Task One - Comprehensively explain how the following concepts impact on the production of factual programming
Here in the UK, we have a set of rules and guidelines set out for Factual Programming in the United Kingdom. This Means that Every Documentary, News Show, and Reality Series must be created from an impartial view point. This means that everything that gets broadcast must have opinions from both sides of the story, this rule is more applied for News Programs; for instance when interviewing Politicians from Different Parties. The Person Conducting the interviews must not be biased towards one particular Politician and questions towards the politicians, must be fair and reasonable. Of course these rules must be followed when Interviewing everyone, not just Politicians.
When Looking at News Programs, Like BBC News or ITV News, they serve a purpose of Delivering the News and what they feel is important for People to know about. Because they are delivering the news to such a wide variety of People, they are supposed to deliver it from an impartial view point, as stated by 'Ofcom' :
"Due impartiality and due accuracy in news
5.1 News, in whatever form, must be reported with due accuracy and presented with due impartiality.
5.2 Significant mistakes in news should normally be acknowledged and corrected on air quickly. Corrections should be appropriately scheduled.
5.3 No politician may be used as a newsreader, interviewer or reporter in any news programmes unless, exceptionally, it is editorially justified. In that case, the political allegiance of that person must be made clear to the audience."
This is because everyone has their own view and opinion and the News broadcasters have to be fair, clear and accurate in the stories they broadcast and the way they broadcast them.
Accuracy.
When creating any kind of Factual Program you must be accurate in what you present and produce. Lets say that you are watching some kind of Factual show that is displaying some form of statistics, whether that be in a chart or table or whatever. The Statistic says, 'One in Five People will die from eating too many chips'. For a start it's probably inaccurate however, i just made it up on the spot. But you normally would need to display something in way of a source (in small print) so that people, if they really wanted to, could check and look at the source and the study which allowed the source to be out. So if you are the one including the information and the statistics, you would normally cite your sources back to the original study or survey.
Because you would normally have to cite your sources, your statistics and sources must be Accurate and the Study or Survey must have been carried out in a fair and non biased manner. This is a rule for anything being broadcast on Television because anyone can watch and everyone is able to for their own opinions except for the broadcasters who are paid not to have an opinion and are supposed to let the viewer form their own opinion. However, there are some News Broadcasters who don't follow this rule. I'm talking about Fox News in America; but i'll talk about them later.
Balance.
During Election Periods Ofcom have rules set in place which disallows any British Broadcaster from being biased towards one particular party.
The BBC is not Just regulated by Ofcom, as it (The BBC) is partially funded by the UK Government as well as the Licence payers. Some Ofcom Regulations do not apply to the BBC because of this, However, the BBC Must still Follows rules about Being Impartial.
This Quote from the BBC Trust Website -
"The BBC exists to serve the public, and its mission is to inform, educate and entertain. The BBC Trust is the governing body of the BBC, and we make sure the BBC delivers that mission."
The BBC Trust governs and controls what can and cannot be broadcast on BBC Television, among other things of course. While Ofcom controls all media outlets in the UK, the BBC Trust Controls only Things that the BBC produces. The BBC Trust is in place to 'get the best out of the BBC for licence fee payers.' and because of this, they must show balanced opinions and not show any biased views on any subject. This is what the BBC Trust is in place for.
Impartiality.
The Subject of Impartiality, goes back on what i covered in the Previous Section (Balance). Broadcasters are normally obliged to be impartial and again, are supposed to have no biased views.
I have covered News Broadcasters a lot so far in this post, but that is only because i am focusing on Television and These issues of Impartiality and subjectivity are often talked about when people talk about how news is broadcast.
The BBC have their own 'Editorial Guidelines' which must be followed by all who work at the BBC. From Section 15: Conflicts of interest - of the BBC's Editorial Guidelines -
"All BBC staff are required formally to declare any personal interest which may affect their work with the BBC. Freelance presenters, reporters, producers and researchers and most other freelances will also be required to declare personal interests which may affect their work with the BBC."
This statement basically asserts some authority on keeping anyone from giving or showing any kind of biased views in Broadcasting. It is in place to keep the broadcasters impartial on any views that may be expressed. The presenters at the BBC are required to be impartial however, they are still human which is why they have to 'declare' any interests before being allowed to present or host a television show. This is so that anyone can watch the show and not feel as though their own views are being constricted to very limited air time.
In America, Fox News is known for having issues with accuracy as mentioned before, but they are also known for what some people call, 'Opinionated News'.
They are known to only report what they want, or only the news which they feel important whether it actually reflects the views of the Public. They have been in hot water on multiple occasions for Misrepresentation, and being Biased, despite their slogan, "Fair and Balanced".
Objectivity and Subjectivity.
Objectivity and Subjectivity is a matter of displaying both facts and opinions in broadcasting. Objectivity is when something is based around facts and facts alone. Or to explain further, You can get Television Shows which are completely factual as opposed to shows in which opinions are expressed, sometimes in the form of facts. When i say 'Completely Factual' i am talking about things like 'Horizon', a Factual Science Show on The BBC or 'The Blue Planet', a David Attenborough Documentary about under Water Life. The content in these shows are backed up by Real Factual Evidence. The 'views' in these shows are objective, they are factually true regardless of anybodies individual views or biases.
Subjective Broadcasting is when a show is more opinionated then factual. Although the show can still be factual, it will still be more opinionated. Sometimes these opinions can be passed off as facts, because sometimes certain opinions can be seen as a more conclusive agreement than an actual factual answer. Whether that be for comedic purposes or simply because that particular person has their facts wrong, or it's there own judgement/biases.
Shows like 'TopGear', are more subjective, because even though it is classed as a Factual Show, it has a lot of opinions being thrown around and these are just the opinions and biases of whoever is making there point clear.
In News shows, you may find that you get a mix of Objective and Subjective Broadcasting. As i have Covered, News Stories Must be accurate to what is going on in Reality otherwise there would be biased views being sprouted from every single News Reader, and non of the broadcasters would be reporting from an Impartial Standpoint. Along with having to Broadcast the News with the facts, They often also get the views and opinions of different people who are involved in whatever is being Reported on. Or if something is being reported on that affects a lot of the general public, they may get the Opinions or the General consensus of what people's views are.
Opinion.
You could say that Opinions in Broadcasting is similar to Subjective Broadcasting. But only really in the sense that they are both about Broadcasting opinions and potentially biased views. When Broadcasting People's opinions, it can quite easily conflict with another opinion. So when these opinions are expressed, it is often made clear that the opinion belongs to that specific person rather than making the opinion represent everyone. This is partially due to the fact that Broadcasters, here in the UK at least, are supposed to remain impartial, but can still allow the public and people to voice there own opinions, but again, it is often that these opinions are clearly being expressed by someone outside of the Broadcaster.
Bias.
As previously covered, FOX News have been in Hot Water on numerous occasions for there overt bias reporting, and their denials of being bias. As News Broadcasters You have the control and the power to broadcast something, and potentially Millions of people will watch and take clear notice of what is being broadcast and take it for face value. This i feel is because there should be an element of trust with News Broadcasters, that what they are reporting, must be true. With FOX News however, That trust simply isn't there for most people because FOX News are what can be referred to as, 'Opinionated Broadcasters'. Opinionated Broadcasting being that they are simply reporting on what they want, and will only Report on it from their view point.
I have already written about FOX News in this post with examples of biased reporting, so i don't want to begin repeating myself, and the purpose of this blog post isn't to call out broadcasters for being biased, but to explain the effects of not following editorial guidelines and why we have guidelines in the first place.
In this day and age, you can get your news from any source on the internet, and you can read through a web article on the internet, and just believe everything it says. (Just to add, I'm thinking more about social media when i say this). You may read the article and be finished with it and move on with your day. The article may not be accurate or may only express the views of whoever wrote the article, so you would only be getting one side of the story. This is why Professional News Broadcasters or Publications are normally required to obey rules and regulations that mean the they must remain impartial when writing or creating a report. The affects of not being impartial could lead to people being misinformed about news stories and that can lead to people not understanding things which are going on around the world to the fullest extent.
***
Task two
News:
- Studio News Readers
A Studio News Reader's Job is to relay the Latest News out to the Public. They are given News and Information from Field Reporters, News Publications, and Their own Researchers Based in Offices, often in the same building as the Television or Radio Studio that the Studio News Readers are based.
The News is normally Constructed to be read out in a specific order. Someone has to decide which story is the Biggest story of the day and must decide which story gets to go first, and how much air time it will get. The Producer Decides the order and must order everything and make sure to have all of the stories complete and ready to go out on air in time.
On the BBC, the News Readers Must Read the News and be completely impartial while doing so. Whether it is from big stories which may be being reported from the Middle east or Eastern Europe, or relatively small story about a minor car accident in which nobody was injured. They are supposed to read the stories displaying the facts and nothing more. If any opinions are expressed, it is from people who are directly involved in the story that is being reported.
- Field Reporters
A Field Reporter is the reporter who is based at specific locations. These locations of course being relevant to the story they are reporting. Their job is to deliver a report of their story that they are covering. Sometimes it is pre-recorded, sometimes they will be reporting live on air. These field reporters can be sent to places all around the world, sometimes a supermarket, sometimes a war-zone. It depends on the Story. Now, you can get different field reporters who specialise in specific stories. You have Nick Robinson, a Political Editor for the BBC. If you see him on the News, he is most likely talking about the goings on in the world of politics. If you see Jeremy Bowen Reporting on the News, he is most likely reporting about what is happening in the Middle East and so on. So where Jeremy Bowen may be based in Libya, Nick Robinson is often seen giving a live news report just outside Number 10.
Field reporters are often sent to a location so that they can report what it is like to be in the midst of the 'action', again, whether that is in a war torn country, or outside a school on Results day.
- Interviews
You May often see interviews being given on Television, sometimes they are done live in studio, sometimes, they are pre-recorded. I think this depends on the availability of the interviewee.
The purpose of interviewing someone for Factual Research and broadcasting, is to get information that you have previously not known or to get answers to specific questions, by asking the person at the source of your queries. Lets say that their was going to be a change to the way the government funded Schools, or the NHS. Broadcasters like the BBC or ITV, may try and get an interview with The Prime Minister or with the the Secretary of State for health, Jeremy Hunt, or even the Chancellor, George Osbourne.
Field Reporters, and Anchors, can be be expected to give interviews, as sometimes it does indeed happen in studio as well as in different locations around the world.
- Experts and Witnesses
For some news stories, you may very well need to bring facts to the table so that everyone who is watching or listening to the News, can understand the stories to the fullest extent. Lets say that there was an Earthquake which may have cause a awful lot of Panic, disaster and destruction. You may need some experts, or in this case a specialist scientist drafted in to help explain the situation. Sometimes these experts will need to speak and hear from Witnesses to be able to fully determine what is going on and to give their best judgment on the situation. You may also see Experts simply giving opinions. Lets say for example, you are watching an interview from Film Director Quentin Tarantino, he may give his opinion on how he thinks Movies may change in the future. Of course he has no way of knowing, but he can certainly give his own honest opinion, about what he thinks may happen.
- Report Structure
News Reports are structured so that the information they facts that they give, are explained in a relatively easy and simple way for the views to watch and understand. Also, if News reports are all mostly Created in the same structured format, then it will also be a little easier, and quicker to edit. This ca help make the process of having some filmed, edited and aired within one day, a little less stressful and can hopefully allow big news stories to come out quicker for the convenience of the Public.
To help explain what i am talking about, here is a video from Charlie Brooker explaining it.
Documentary Formats -
- Realism
When you think of Documentaries, you may think of the work from David Attenborough, Louis Theroux, and Michael Moore. The Work from These three people and many more are real factual Documentaries. Watch this Clip below. It is a Segment from a Louis Theroux Documentary.
When watching this Clip, you can see that it is just Louis Theroux asking People Questions on camera. This Documentary was about people in Prison, and wanted to speak to the people on the inside to see how prison life works for them, so he decided to just go ahead and ask them some questions. With Permission of course. Louis Theroux Remained impartial as he wants to learn about these people, and he is very much the same in all of his documentaries from my knowledge.
Then you get factual Science Documentaries, like 'The Blue Planet' with David Attenborough. In David Attenborough Documentaries, you are essentially watching to learn Facts about things that Scientific Research can tell us and teach us about nature and life.
- Dramatisation
Just Because a Documentary needs to be factual, that doesn't mean that it can't involve people acting. What i mean by this is that if there was a documentary about a real event, but it was a time before cameras and Television, then you may want to create a 'DocuDrama' or a 'DocuSoap'. A DocuDrama can basically be an historically correct Television Series which focus' on Historical or factual events, or be about the life of a person with historical significance.
- Narrativisation
We watch Television Shows, and Movies that have a story. The Way the Story is being told can make a huge difference in how the audience can perceive that story. It can have a different impact on the audience depending on how its told. The Director, or the Writer would be the Dictator of the way they want that story to be Perceived by people as they watch. The Stories or Screenplays get written, planned and coordinated down to the smallest detail before filming even starts. This is to make sure that the film can be film and will turn out to be exactly what the Director wants. However with a standard documentary, there is no script, there is no real coordination from producer to directer to writer, because, its like you are filming something without a script. The Script Hasn't been Written yet because it is happening in the moment it is being filmed.
Going back to that Clip with Louis Theroux. Sure, there will have been some amount of planning that went into his visit to that prison to meet those inmates. But he, nor did anyone else know how that meeting would turn out. Louis Theroux may have very well prepared some questions before hand, but those inmates could have answered in any way they pleased.
A lot of the magic in Documentaries happens in the editing Process. To Quote:
"The difficulty with documentaries often comes during the editing when a story must be crafted from the "rubble" -- the bits and pieces that have been gathered along the way. Whereas a narrative movie has already been scripted ahead of time."
- http://www.desktop-documentaries.com/martin-scorsese.html
No comments:
Post a Comment